Q & A for writers

Email me questions at Martha@Engber.com and I'll answer.

Thursday, October 9, 2008

First Pages, First Impressions

We're a culture of first impressions, where if the right image isn't presented, we give little thought to a second chance, because really, who has the time?

The same seems to happen when we read. We rely heavily on that first page to convince us the time spent reading that particular story won't be wasted.

It's no wonder, then, that as writers we're so worried about grabbing readers' attention that we fall into the First Page Formula Rut.

The formula goes like this: introduce a character in the midst of a desperate action, like a dodging a bullet, followed by action, action, action written in plain, no-frills language, then cut to the second chapter before the reader has time to breathe or think. The character's desperation stems from a situation, rather than a state of mind, and resembles, in both action and writing, the opening of a movie.

Yet we're writing books and seem to have lost what's so amazing about this medium, that we can be in the characters' heads and use language, rather than situations, to create the drama.

Here's an example of what I mean from Democracy, a novel by Joan Didion published in 1984:

The light at dawn during those Pacific tests was something to see.

Something to behold.

Something that could almost make you think you saw God, he said.

He said to her.

Jack Lovett said to Inez Victor.

Inez Victor who was born Inez Christian.

He said: the sky was this pink no painter could approximate, one of the detonation theorists used to try, a pretty fair Sunday painter, he never got it. Just never captured it, never came close. The sky was this pink and the air was wet from the night rain, soft and wet and smelling like flowers, smelling like those flowers you used to pin in your hair when you drove out to Schofield, gardenias, never mind there were not too many flowers around those shot islands.


This is what I look for in a first page of a novel, exciting writing that hauls me off into another world.

What first page does that for you?

Happy writing.

Monday, October 6, 2008

The Rewriter

I taught a workshop on The Art of Rewriting this weekend in beautiful Carmel-by-the-Sea, where I spent the day talking to fourteen other writers about what, when and how to rewrite.

One of those writers was Deborah Rich, a freelance journalist aiming "for a part-time position at a newspaper and a book contract." She came to my workshop on Saturday and by 12:33 p.m. Sunday sent the following email:

I just finished editing a set of three articles due to the San Francisco Chronicle next week. Thanks to your workshop, yesterday, I had a mental rewriting map to guide me and to help me remember all the aspects of the rewriting process.


Finished editing three articles, and within less than 24 hours between the lesson and completion. Now there's a writer who has become a rewriter, a title bestowed on those one step closer to success — or greater success — as a professional wordsmith.

Deborah's ability to immediately apply the lessons she learned proves she absorbed what was most important: rewriting is not about following one particular method, but rather about creating your own method from all available tools. While the former can lead to frustration from round-peg-in-a-square-hole syndrome, the latter allows you to be who you are and so get the job done as you see fit.

How do you rewrite? Why does that method work for you? How long do you take to rewrite something?

Let me know.

Happy writing!